Hello, and welcome, everyone. My name is Britt Barker. I'm our senior vice president of sales here at Origence. It's been twenty two years today. Can you believe that? So some of you that I've known over the years. But, we are excited to have you today, for the webinar on the affordability squeeze. Before we begin, a quick housekeeping note. Your lines are muted during today's presentation. However, we want your participation in the questions and answers, q and a section. There's a big difference between chat and q and a and Zoom. Q and a, we gotta keep that. And that way, we can follow-up if we run out of time where chat goes right away. Okay? So now it is my pleasure to introduce our speaker. Joining us today is TJ ***. Such a great last name. TJ is the senior director of market development for TransUnion's automotive business, where he helps lenders connect the realities of the auto ecosystem to the data and insights that can improve how they compete. His perspective shaped by an eighteen year career at TransUnion that started in information technology and included stops in research and development and solutions consulting before arriving at his current role in market development for the automotive side of the house. That progression from building the systems, developing capabilities, to applying them alongside customers still defines how TJ approaches his work. He starts with the challenge the lender is facing, brings the data research solution and expertise to bear on it. In his current role, TJ's strategy for TransUnion automotive business and brings new solutions to market. He leads and contributes to the industry research behind TransUnion's auto thought leadership on affordability, consumer credit behavior, origination trends, and fraud risk, and translates those findings into guidance lenders can act on in underwriting, pricing, deal structure, and all important portfolio management. He's a frequent speaker at auto finance and industry events. TJ is known for making data practical, explaining not just what is changing in consumer behavior and the market, but also how those dynamics impact auto lenders. It should be noted he holds a bachelor's from Oklahoma State and a master's in economic research from the University of North Texas. TJ resides in Iowa with his wife, Lindsey, their dog, Zoey. And earlier as we're chatting, we both realized we are both big 12 school fans, and I find it noteworthy that TJ, during his college days, was in the marching band of the Oklahoma State University on the drum line. Can you just see it? I can see him out there just banging away, getting everyone hyped up for that college game day. So welcome, TJ. I'm excited as others. We've got hundreds of credit unions here, so let's jump in. Awesome. Thanks, Brent. Really appreciate the intro there, and congratulations on a big milestone. We've been chatting for a couple of times over the last couple of days getting ready for this, and he buried the lead that today was a a big anniversary for him. So congrats to that, Britt. I really appreciate that. We've also been chatting a lot about college football, a big win for for Brits' BYU cougars this weekend over Notre Dame. So sorry if you're a Notre Dame fan and on the call, but we can we can definitely... Next time you see me at a conference event, I'm always happy to talk college sports and college football. So we'll get into the conversation here. We're gonna start with, yeah, this conversation around affordability as I get my slides here to to to advance through. I think we're all pretty familiar with the headlines that we've been seeing over, really, the last few years with respect to kind of macroeconomic conditions of, you know, kind of some of the inflationary inflections that we've had over the last few years across the entire macroeconomic situation. But, specifically, with respect to autos, you know, you know, I think some of these headlines probably resonate with you. Right? American consumers losing patience with high car prices from the Wall Street Journal earlier this this summer. Consumers having to downsize buying used vehicles instead of new taking longer longer loans to be able to manage those monthly payments. Broader overall ownership costs causing some financial strain. Right? Whether that's, we'll see some details on this, whether that's insurance costs, maintenance costs, and more recently, over the last six or seven months, fuel prices as as the conflict in The Middle East continues to elevate our gas prices and diesel prices. But then also the... Just the the the the more expensive new car that we see within the market over the last couple of years, whether that's increases in technology in the car or tariff impacts to the prices of those cars, also being challenged, challenging, definitely the middle part of the the consumer risk tiers. But, all of that has really been impacting, and kinda created this affordability crunch, that we've seen within the auto finance market. And so because of that, we decided here at TransUnion to kinda take a look at what this affordability squeeze actually looks like. So over the course of the next forty five minutes or so, forty minutes or so, we're gonna go through these three sections with the study with the study that we just published and released just a couple of weeks ago. We're gonna start with kinda defining and talking a little bit more detail about the affordability squeeze and the impact of that across the entire kinda macroeconomic and the automotive space specifically. And then we're really gonna get into the meat of this, which is how buying and financing choices drive loan performance for those particular auto trade lines. And then finally, we'll wrap it up with what it means for auto lenders and you guys specifically in the credit union space. So let's get started with that affordability squeeze. So let's just kinda lay some foundational work here. Right? Mark, there's... As you can see here on the chart, and I think everybody on the phone's pretty familiar with on the call today, the auto market has had challenge after challenge after challenge since about 2019. Right? When you first start on this left hand side of this chart, you think about the things... The the events that have occurred over the six year period. Right? First, we had the demand shock of of the COVID nineteen pandemic. Right? Dealerships shut down. Demand was kinda built up because of that until kinda dealerships and the economy opened back up, and then boom. Tons of demand, tons of consumers coming back into market to replace or transact their next vehicle that they kinda had to hold off to. Well... And then we move into 2021. So right after all of that demand surge from the from kind of the the the release of the pent up demand from COVID pandemic. Now we run into logistical challenges for moving cars and more specifically chip shortages that caused some cons... Some supply constraints on the new vehicle side and shift demand over to the used vehicles. That's where you see that that dark blue line there on the used monthly payment really shoot up as demand kinda shifted into that segment. Then in the second quarter of twenty twenty two, we get interest increases, and those start coming out quarter after quarter for about two year period there. And so now our financing costs are starting to increase in line with more expensive vehicles through that same time period. And then we get a little bit of relief throughout '24. We actually get some interest rate relief in that time frame as well a couple times through late twenty... Through '24 and into '25. And now we're under trade pressure, and that's where vehicle and part tariffs are really starting to trickle into the system and and and and cause some some challenges on the actual price of the vehicle side of things. So it's been one thing after another, and all of this has created this affordability crisis that we see across the industry. But it's not just the cost of those vehicles and the cost of financing those vehicles that is also creating some pressure on the consumer. When we look at total vehicle cost of ownership and comparing that to our CPI basket here, you could see that over the course of that same time frame, other costs have increased pretty dramatically. We talk about insurance costs, which effectively have in... Didn't even start their increase until the later parts of 2021 and early twenty two, and now those numbers are up almost 50% in that time frame. Maintenance costs, labor, parts, all of those components into that maintenance cost have also accelerated those numbers up approximately 52% since the beginning of twenty twenty. And then fuel. Fuel was a concern in '22. That pressure released. And then, with the conflict in The Middle East now, over the last six to seven months, we've seen, you know, some increase in fuel costs there as well. All of this, kind of culminating into this broader, affordability crisis, not just so much on the price of the vehicle and the cost of financing, but other components that consumers have to have to consider when making that next vehicle transaction. When we take a look at what we expected to see from an originations perspective in 2025 versus what we actually saw, we calculate that we have approximately 3,700,000 lost originations of consumers that just did not return to market for a variety of reasons. Right? Affordability definitely being one of those challenges that contributed to that 12% reduction of what we expected to see in in in originations in in 2025. So with that as the groundwork and kind of the baseline of what we see challenging consumers from an affordability perspective, now let's get into the study of what we and how... Of what we looked at and how we looked at it with respect to the buying and the financing choices and how those drive the loan performance for consumers that did return back into market. So when we thought about this and we've... When when the team and I were trying to figure out, hey. How do we wanna, you know, really, you know, kind of, like, simplify this conversation of, you know, what a consumer has to decide and how they make those decisions and what influences those decisions? We kinda started to separate it out into two buckets, and you could kinda see those two buckets here. At its simplest form, it's what you buy from a consumer perspective, and we're talking about the vehicle decisions and those outcomes. And then the second piece is how do you pay for it. Right? How do you finance that decision, right, that that vehicle transaction? If we start with what to buy, we're looking at the actual vehicles that the consumers did... Transacted and purchased and compared that to what they used to have. Right? So we're talking about did consumers move to buying a new vehicle to buying a used vehicle. We're talking about maybe buying a higher trim package or maybe a third row SUV to buying a more basic trim package or or actually downsizing the size of the vehicle down to a two row SUV. We're talking about maybe a brand that has or is known to have a higher maintenance cost to a brand that is known to have lower maintenance costs. So all of those, we bucket into the category of the consumer making this decision on what they were going to buy. And then you've got the secondary piece, which is, well, how did you pay for it? Right? How did you finance it? And these are the things that you guys are probably more familiar with and and and and recognize in your own portfolios. What about longer terms? Do consumers... Are consumers taking seventy two month notes and eighty four month notes now where they used to take a sixty month note in a prior origination? What about APRs? Are they shopping? Are they refinancing after the fact to lower that total interest cost? Did they go from retailing the car with a loan to actually leasing the vehicle to be able to lower that monthly cost? And then, obviously, payment to income reductions. Like, are... Have they done things, right, longer terms, bigger down payments to lower that payment to get into a different payment to income ratio? Those are the two buckets and some of the things that we're gonna be taking a look at when we start to try to determine, okay, how are consumers reacting on... In... Within these two pieces of the transaction? So here's our study hypothesis. This is what we decided that we wanted to take a look at. Proof of consumers and lenders who adjust their vehicle purchase or financing behaviors in response to this macro affordability pressure experience better performance outcomes. So that's the hypothesis that we walked into this study for. And so now let's talk about how we decided to try to measure and test this hypothesis. So first thing that we did is we gotta go define a cohort, and everybody loves the great fishbone chart here if you're in the analytics of the research space. But we studied specifically auto borrowers who traded in or sold another vehicle. So they disposed of one vehicle for another vehicle and specifically looking at consumers that did that in 2024. We chose 2024 for two reasons. One, that gave us a decent time period, six year window that we could go back to. So that's two years before the COVID pandemic to be able to look back and say, okay. Well, what did they have before this transaction in 2024? So we take everybody that that originated a new loan in 2024. We look back in a six year window, and we say, oh, did that consumer have another registration in this six month win... Or six year window, and can we prove that they disposed of that vehicle as part of this 2024 transaction that were... That landed them here in the cohort? And then, of course, the second piece of that, right, we wanna say, hey. What's the impact to performance based on some of these different decisions? And so then we give us a twelve month window post origination, so looking at 2025, and using that 2025 calendar year, that that one year time window post origination to observe the credit performance during the first twelve months on book following that origination. What that comes down to, our actual final number here is about 5,500,000 consumers that financed a vehicle transaction with a loan and or or or a lease in 2024. So that's our starting population. We're gonna take that 5,500,000 consumers. Just a couple of summary statistics about that population just so you feel comfortable with what our population is here. You could see the credit risk distribution here using vantagescore4.o. About 57.4% of those consumers are above prime, so that's seven twenty one VantageScore and above. 1,100,000 or about 20.4% in the prime space, six sixty one to seven twenty. And then we've got 1,200,000 kind of in that non prime, so below... So six sixty and below. And as you can see, our population also rank orders risk as expected. So these two things make us feel pretty good about the population of consumers that we that we analyze for for the for the study that we're gonna walk through today. So how we chose to kinda measure this and and measure our hypothesis and test our hypothesis is with the segmentation model. And I'm not gonna get into the super analytical weeds of what a segmentation model is and how it works and all the intricacy that comes along with it. But, effectively, we wanted to measure, take a bunch of independent variables, and we want to see if we can build various segments that then have a a a... Predict the risk or the performance of those loans. Right? So our independent variables that we're starting with here are those two buckets that we talked about. Vehicle characteristics, what you bought, what did the consumer buy versus the financing characteristics, which is how they paid for it. Right? And you can see some of the some of the broad based variables that go into the independent side of our of our model. So then we take those independent variables, and we actually ran three separate segmentation models. Again, I'm not gonna go into the into the weeds of how those segmentation models work, but effectively, we ran one model for the nonprime space. Again, 300 to six sixty on the VantageScore four dot o scale. We built a second model for prime, six sixty one to seven twenty VantageScore four dot o. And then we built a third model for above prime, seven twenty one and above. And the reason we we did this is we wanted to see, hey. Based on risk, were there different balances or different segments that were created? But two, we kinda wanted to hold credit score constant. Right? We wanted to say, given the credit score being constant or at least in the same range here, what are the determining factors of loan performance based on what they bought and how they financed it? What that turns into... Or our or our actual performance variable here... I'm trying to... Is our dependent variable here, sorry, is the performance, as I mentioned before. 12 performance compared within the same risk tier. Right? And that's our battery differentiation. We're gonna see some pretty interesting stats as we go through here. So this segmentation model, we rolled up into what we called three persona. Right? Three very, very distinct consumer personas which in... Within all three credit risk buckets that we looked at. So if you had better than tier performance... So based on the risk tier that you were in, the performance was actually better than the average. When we look at those consumers, we started we started to call them the prudent purchasers. Why? Well, they were responsible buyers. They kept the vehicle and the financing choices comfortably within their means, and the performance kinda shows the impact of it afterwards. If the performance was kinda at par with tier... With the with the tier... With the average, delinquency rate, we kinda call those consumers the affordability managers. They were... They're a little stretched in the middle, but they adapt given that situation. So their vehicle choices changed, and their financing decisions were different to be able to manage those monthly payments, those increased monthly payments effectively. And then finally, the third group, which is worse than tier performance. So these consumers, as you will see, had some pretty significant increases in delinquency. We called that group the the affordability stretched group. So either they were already in a situation where they had pretty limited vehicle choices to begin with, or they continued to keep the status quo with the size or trim or or or level of expense that their vehicle cost them. Right? So those are the two things. And then they didn't adjust their financing options reflectively based on that purchase. So they continue to do the same financing, have some of the same challenges on that side as well. So these were the three personas that we created, and we're gonna apply each of these personas to each of the three credit risk tiers or or more boxes that we talked about prior to. So we'll get started. Apologies for taking some... Taking a quick drink there. We'll start with the nonprime personas as we move through the credit risk spectrum here. And so, again, just looking at that nonprime space, 300 to six sixty Vantage score four .o and applying our three different personas via that segmentation model that I described, we start to see some pretty interesting insights here. And you're gonna definitely identify a pattern as we kinda go through these different insights. We're gonna highlight some interesting things within each risk tier. So despite nearly identical credit scores here within that nonprime space, we could see the consumers that... In that affordability stretched persona have about 6.7 times higher delinquency rate than the consumers that made a prudent decision with prudent financing options. K? Our nonprime average here was 4.93%. Your affordability managers run just underneath that at about a 4.7% rate. Again, this rate is sixty plus days past due within the first twelve months of the origination date. And as you can see, the prudent purchasers are running almost four times lower delinquency rate than the actual segment average here. So just on loan performance, we can definitely see that our three personas have very different outcomes here with those affordability stretched running at almost almost... Pretty close to 9% at 8.1 per sick... Eight point six one percent delinquency rate here. But some other interesting stuff. When we look at the account distribution here, about 24% of these consumers in this space were in that prudent purchasers, but they actually only make up 6.1% of all delinquency within the space. When you look at the affordability stretch, that's on the opposite end of the spectrum. So of only 25% of our consumers in this nonprime space fit in that affordability stretched persona, but that persona accounts for 44.5%, nearly half of all of the losses or delinquency that we see in this segment. So right away, you can see that, you know, based on the segmentation model and the personas that are the outcome of it, consumers, even in the nonprime space, consumers that make a good solid vehicle purchase decision coupled with a with a good solid financing decision do end up performing better than consumers that do not. But let's get into the details of some of this a little bit more. So when we look at financing choices, including PTI, those things are the most impactful things in this particular nonprime segment. Right? PTI, almost 52% impact here. Right? Term length, 20% LTV. Those things we would expect to see. But the but the vehicle decision is also a pretty important piece here as we see that moving from a higher to a lower cost vehicle actually contributed 7% to the model. Switching to an older vehicle, 5.5 contribution to the model. I wanna pause there on switching to older vehicle. Let me just give you an example of what that actually means. So if I... If if if consumers in this population... Let's say they bought in 2024, let's say they bought a 2021 model year used car. So that would be a three year old car when they purchased it in 2024. If their previous transaction in that six year window before, let's say they bought a used car, but it was actually only a two year used car... Two year old used car on that prior purchase, they actually switched to an older vehicle. They went from a two year old used car to a three year old used car. That would land them in this category of switching to an older vehicle. Obviously, going from a new to a used car also lands in that switch to older vehicles. Just wanted to be clarify that and and and let you guys understand kinda how we designated that. But either way, as you can see here, two of the top five most impactful attributes to our segmentation model in that non prime segment were definitely aligned around vehicle choice, just showing the impact of what that decision has on the performance of the loan at the end of the day. So let's get into a little bit more details. When we created the segmentation model, we actually created eight different segments. We collapsed those into these three personas because we saw some similar traits. And as we look at this, you could see from our... From the segment that has the best performance in this nonprime space, this PTI below 6%, LTV below one one hundred percent, phenomenal low risk consumer even in this nonprime space, all the way up to our worst performing segment here. Consumers that had a PTI above 17% and no other considerations really from that point, there's an 18 x change in performance of the loan. So pretty wide spectrum here. And with that wide spectrum, that actually allows us to to really see some meaningful differences across some of the different combinations of of, independent variables that we saw. So let's highlight just a couple of, more meaningful ones here from our perspective. When we look in the affordability manager space, you see this bottom segment here that runs at a 6.11%, delinquency rate, PTI of 11 to 17%, LTV less than a 130%, and they did not do any meaningful switch on the type of vehicle that they chose. When you actually compare that to the lower... To the best performing segment in the affordability stretched, the the the main driving difference here is the LTV change. And and there's probably some of you on the phone who are like, yep. Absolutely, TJ. That makes total sense. This isn't new to me. That's great. That's wonderful. We actually love to see some of this stuff that really solidifies what our typical assumptions are. Right? So same PTI, but that higher LTV shifts that risk about 1.2 x riskier for that group. Let's highlight a couple more. When we look just within the affordability manager space here, when we kinda highlight those first two, you see what we bolded there. That first group that runs at 3.02% delinquency rate switched to a lower cost vehicle. The next one down. They actually had no switch there. Right? When we compare to the next group down, so those next two, you see some of the impact of switching to a lower cost vehicle or not switching. Right? So on that first group, we have PTI six to 11%. Both of those both of those segments have the same PTI, similar terms, 68 to 72 versus just everybody being less than 72. But what's the big material difference? About 1.5 x riskier by not switching on the vehicle side. Same thing for that next PTI segment even within the affordability managers. The 11 to 17% dealt, PTI, 100 and per... 130% or lower LTV. What's the gap here? Well, the difference is consumer that switches to an older vehicle runs at about a about a 30... 25 to 30 basis point better delinquency rate than the... Those consumers who chose not to switch vehicles. Definitely pointing to the fact that, yes, given all things constant, that vehicle decision does have a meaningful impact to the, performance on the loan attached to that transaction. And then finally, the last thing I'll highlight here within the nonprime space, when we look at those prudent purchasers, again, PTI below 6%, LTV greater than a 100%, but the term is longer than seventy two months. Right? Compared to same PTI, no vehicle switch, term shorter than seventy two, we actually see an improvement in the delinquency with the consumers that that that take on that longer loan. Now we all pretty much understand why the consumer probably takes that longer loan. Right? They wanna lower that monthly payment. That lower monthly payment puts them into a different PTI bucket. Right? And that lower PTI bucket then definitely leads to better outcomes for the loan compared to somebody in a slightly higher BTI bucket. So, again, some things that some of you are probably seeing on the screen say, hey. This is really, really great information. I kinda already knew this. But, hey. Now we could see it really proven out within the data leveraging our segmentation model that we built out here. So let's take one step in the in the northerly direction with respect to the credit risk tiers, and let's let's hone in on just the prime purse... Prime personas here. And, again, the prime segment here, $6.61 to seven twenty on that VantageScore four dot o range. And we see a similar story. Right? Again, I mentioned at the top, you're gonna see some familiar patterns as we move through the credit risk spectrum here. Prime average delinquency rate, again, that's sixty plus days past due within the first twelve months, 1.08 for this segment. We could see that the prudent purchasers run about two x lower than that, a little more than two x lower than that. And our affordability managers are slightly underneath that average. Right? Where we see some of the more challenged consumers is, again, in that affordability stretched space where they don't change their vehicle decision, and they didn't really adjust their financing to to account for the affordability concerns that they might have had. When we look at the distributions here, we actually see that 42.5% of our accounts in that prime space are actually prudent purchasers. And we we we we think that that makes a lot of sense. Right? Consumers that are in the prime space probably manage their their their finances just a touch better, don't have as much challenges as we see sometimes in some of the lower risk tiers. And, therefore, those prudent purchasers, do a little bit over index here within the prime space than they did in that non prime space. But when we go to the other side of the fence here, we look at the affordability stretched. Only 20% of our accounts within this prime segment landed in that affordability stretched persona, but yet that accounts for 47% of all of our delinquencies. Definitely seeing some sort of, approving some sort of correlation of affordability stretched does correlate with a higher delinquency rate across the board. So, again, we'll look at the, the impactful attributes within our model. Couple things I'll highlight here. One, our LTV and term length actually swapped order as we moved into the prime space. Right? So term length as term... In our in our non prime space, if you remember, term length was a little bit higher, meaning that, you know, longer terms actually showed a little bit of a better ink... Outcome on there, and that term was definitely indicative of what the end... The loan performance outcome actually ended up being. Here, we actually switched the order. LTV is a little bit more important here, actually twice as important as term linked in that prime segment. Now... But at the same time, we still have vehicle decisioning being a very, very important piece here. So, again, switch to older vehicle or going from new to used specifically showed a bigger impact here within the prime persona model that we built out. Again, we'll go through this exercise where we take a look at the prudent purchasers versus the affordability management and affordability stretched. When, again, you go from the best performing segment, prudent purchasers that have a PTI below four and a half percent all the way up to the affordability stretch PTI, worst performing their PTI above 16%. We have a very similar increase in delinquency about 17 times from the best performing segment to the worst performing segment. In nonprime, it was 18 times from the best performing to the worst performing segment. But just like we did, let's talk about some of the more intricate details and differences between some of these different groups. When we look at these two... When we when we straddle the line between the affordability managers up to the affordability stretched, pretty similar consumer here. Right? PTI, nine to 16%. LTVs above 130%. Those are the two commonalities between these two segments. Again, you'll notice the impact of the vehicle purchase decision. These affordability managers that only run at about a 1.07% delinquency rate switched to an older vehicle. Right? So they made a different decision on the vehicle purchase where we see our affordability stretch consumers there chose not to do that. There was no switch to an older vehicle, and that did increase the delinquency rate there by about 60% between those two segments. Even within the prudent purchasers, there are differences here that that can drive, different performance outcomes on the loan itself. When we look at, these two segments, again, what's common? 4.5 to 9% PTI. LTV is less than a 120%. What was the defining difference? Change in term. So our prudent purchasers have a great delinquency rate as it is, point 44% on average for the whole segment there. But by going from a term that's longer than forty eight months or to a term that's less than forty eight months, we do see some change, about 30% change in the performance of those loans, based on the difference in the, in the term there. And so finally, we'll go through the above prime segments. And, again, this segment is that seven sixty one and above segments. So all of your prime plus is super prime according to VantageScore 4.o. And as you can probably imagine, as you've seen, like, the segments kind of start to get a little bit smaller here as we move into some of the more lower risk segments here. Right? So for above prime, the risk stays pretty low across the board, but still, there's about an eight x jump here between our best performing segment versus our worst performing segment. And as you can see, there's really not too terribly much different there, but, absolutely, vehicle purchase starts to play into it a little bit. So as we look at this, we can see our our numbers here, 8.1% PTI in the prudent purchasers compared to 8.1% PTI or more, but yet they still switch to a lower cost vehicle. Does it make the loan performance change a little bit, but still well, you know, probably within most of our thresholds that we would be happy to. Within the... Within this above prime space, really in the affordability stretch, it was... That's where we start to see kind of the interesting story here. Right? So, again, both of these in the prudent purchaser and that affordability stretch category, PTI is above 8.1%. Right? That's the commonality. Again, where we start to see the impact of the consumer decision is when a consumer switched to a lower cost vehicle, that's where we saw a pretty significant improvement in the delinquency rate versus the customer that did not switch to a lower cost vehicle. 3.2 times riskier when they do not make that switch versus when they do make that switch. So I think we start to see across all of the risk spectrums as we go across here, across every single tier, we found that vehicle adapters outperformed comparable non, nonadapters on the vehicle decision side of things. Right? When we looked at non prime, if we were specifically isolated within that PTI of six to 11%, the consumers that have adapted their vehicle purchase also going with a long... Longer term and a lower cost vehicle, they only had about a 3.02% bad rate. Again, sixty plus days past due in the first twelve months. Those that did not adapt, so no vehicle switch. Right? They actually performed at all. 1.5 x worse than those that adapted. Same story here within the prime space. Holding constant PTI and the LTV, those that switched to an older vehicle versus those that did not switch, 1.6% worse. And then finally, common theme here in the above prime space. Again, PTI above 8.1% was really the only determining factor from kind of the credit side of the house. Really, what made the biggest difference is the consumer that made that switch to a lower cost vehicle for the... Versus those that did not switch, 3.2 x worse. So across each score segment, vehicle choice really starts to separate risk beyond what the score and the PTI can even capture. So from our perspective, we think that we absolutely held our study hypothesis. Prudent consumers and lenders who adjust those vehicle purchase or the financing behavior in response to this affordability pressure that everybody's experiencing within the market definitely experience better performance outcomes on the loan or the lease after the fact. So a couple of key learnings that we wanted to highlight here. So first, financing and vehicle choice do provide useful risk signals beyond the credit score and the lead, and lead to different performance as we showed within, the the three different credit tier buckets that we, that we studied. Financing choice does still matter the most. Right? Within the bounds of our study, PTI was absolutely the most predictive. You saw it rank very, very high across the board, across all three of those, model segmentation slides that we show. Longer terms appear to help consumers when used to lower monthly payments, but not when used to buy more vehicle. And this is the common thread that why... That I had heard anecdotally from custom... From from lenders and other players in the industry. And there was a concern that, you know, if I went to... From a seventy two month note to an eighty four month note, that actually would lower my payments by more than what it actually needed to. But then the dealer then would necessarily say, well, actually, you know, seventy two month note at $750. If I move it to 84, that actually gets you to $6.75. But you told me you needed to be under 700, I can actually get you more car on the eighty four month note than the seventy two month note. That seems like a really great option for the consumer. They get to buy more car, but what our study has shown is that when longer terms appear to help consumers, they don't help as much when the the longer term loan is used to buy more expensive or a higher transaction cost vehicle. High LTVs in conjunction with a marginal PTI leads to the worst payment performance. Right? If the consumer is bringing negative equity to the transaction, they have a high LTV, they don't have the additional equity, they're just on this... Just on the edge of what their budget can handle, the first sign of concern or impact to their monthly budget causes the constraint. And then because of the high LTV, they realize they're they're they're probably not gonna be able to get ahead, and it just kinda deteriorates from there. We definitely kinda showed that across the board within our study here. And then finally, vehicle choices also do play a role. As we highlighted in the previous slide, it does matter. Vehicle choice absolutely matters. Borrowers who adapt their vehicle choice are materially less risky. Right? They take on less of a debt burden. They buy that cheaper car. They move... They buy a lower trim package. Whatever that is, whatever decision that is to be a prudent purchaser absolutely plays an impact... An impactful role in the outcome of the loan itself. So what does this mean for lenders? And then we'll open it up for some questions. So first, obviously, assessing the portfolio risk. Right? Looking at your existing portfolio, doing this extra analysis to be able to identify where PTI term, LTV, and vehicle choice do reveal even within the same risk score some potential segments that that that could be taken a deeper dive into. Obviously, portfolio reviews, market intelligence tools, including credit data, collateral information can help facilitate that type of above portfolio assessment. From refining the deal structure at origination, right, verifying the capacity that the consumer actually has for a monthly payment, using term to lower that payment where it's meaningful, right, but not necessarily to finance more vehicle. Right? So when that deal comes across the desk of a seventy seventy two month note and moves it to an eighty four, making sure that the collateral stays the same definitely shows signs of a of a of a difference in loan performance. Engaging your dealers to consider other vehicle options and structure options. Right? Dealer education is always a big component of any lender dealer relationship, but refining that to be a little bit more detailed, making sure they aren't rolling a consumer into a more expensive vehicle given a longer term loan and and maybe more buying capacity. Those types of partnership conversations are gonna be very, very valuable as well. You know, from a product solutions perspective that you might take a look at, you know, trending in alternative data, trying to get that full complete view of the consumer income verification, also very, very key in that PTI calculation and conversation as well. And then finally, understanding lost sales. Right? So evaluating declines, looking at unbooked approvals. Right? Maybe you said no to a consumer and may... You know, maybe because they were in a credit buy box that you weren't privy to or didn't wanna necessarily take a look at, but understanding that there might be other things. And then through the lens of these personas, you might be able to identify missed growth opportunities and and and and membership growth opportunities as well. Obviously, being able to leverage lost sales analysis, including richer, more robust data, can help facilitate some of those perspectives. So that'll con... That'll conclude the content that I have today. Absolutely open to answering some questions, hopefully, in our q and a. There's some really meaningful ones here. But, Brett, I'll open it back up to you to see what we got from a q and a perspective. We do. We do have several, TJ. And, you know, as I I listened to you go through that, lending to the borrower or lending to the collateral. Right? That's often been in... Over the years. Who are you who are you lending to? And I'm kinda seeing a blend, and this and this first question gets into kinda more of the collateral. In in your segmentation analysis, how are you defining lower cost vehicles? Is this simply the relative price, or does this include anything around reliability, maintenance, energy efficiency? Yeah. It's definitely the latter there. So we took kinda known... We took a dataset of known kinda average maintenance cost by brand and model combination, and we were able to kinda take that information and say, hey. You know, if if a consumer... I don't wanna call out any one particular brand or anything about not being, you know, the most cost efficient maintenance, but, you know, there's a couple luxury brands that are known that at a certain time frame, hey. Boom. You're gonna have some maintenance cost as part of the deal, and you're not gonna have any more for another time period after that, but there's gonna be some. Right? If you're moving from one of those known kinda higher cost maintenance brands, right, to a... What is a known more lower cost maintenance brand, that was part of our definition here of moving to a lower cost vehicle. Energy efficiency, a thousand percent part of that conversation as well. Right? If you went from an internal combustion engine to a hybrid or to an EV or a hybrid to an EV, absolutely, that is part of moving to a lower cost vehicle. So definitely the latter part there wasn't just necessarily lower cost. We felt like we actually captured that by by the the attributes of new to used, identify a lower cost vehicle moving from an... Even if you went from used to used, but you picked an older vehicle for that second transaction. We kinda bundled those and felt like those identified actual transaction cost changes. We wanted to look at it a little bit more holistically and actually say, hey. Maintenance, gas, insurance, etcetera, etcetera, known cheaper brands for for those... For that part of the affordability calculation. Staying with that thought, we've got three or four that just came in. In that lower cost vehicle, is there prepaid maintenance, service contract, the typical back end items that are often sold? How did you evaluate those? Yeah. Great question. We did not evaluate those, because our data shows an all in amount finance. So if those packages are built into the monthly payment or if they're built into the actual amount financed as a, you know, a $2,000, for example, extended warranty, and that is being financed as part of the cost of the vehicle, That's all kinda baked in. We did not necessarily break that stuff out. We don't have the visibility into the deal jacket that it would actually allow us to do that. Definitely taking a note. Great question. We have some other industry partners that we might be able to bring into the study that we could actually use to to help identify those. Yeah. That is always a big deal with loan to... Right? It's... Oh my gosh. Here's the service contract. Do I... But that that keeps my borrower in the car. You know, they'll keep making payments. Right? Often discussions. Hey. Props to this anonymous attendee. Hey. Sorry. Can you say what PTI stands for? Yes. I love the acronym that I I do that in my... In our company. Like, we have to say payment to income. Right? Yep. Let's let's not assume anything. Yeah. My apologies for that. I should know better. Payment to income, that's PTI. So one of the calculations that some lenders will definitely leverage, some lenders don't. It kinda just depends on what your risk profile is, where you're playing, what your what your program looks like. But it is just a flat ratio of what's the monthly payment. Compare that to your monthly income. That creates a PTI ratio. Other other ways you may hear a debt to income. So DTI or debt to income ratio, that's overall debt required payments compared to your monthly income. That might be another thing that you would hear as well. Okay. We've got a lively audience. Here comes some more, Andrew. With the repossession inventory increasing and the MMR, I think that's Manheim market rate values declining at auction, what front end book out strategies can help minimize the gap between the origination value and the auction recovery value, particularly on those higher loan to value stretch approvals? Great question. Phenomenal question. And I I think on... We could probably spend the whole hour answering this question, to be honest. I think on the front end side of things, I think it's... If you've got a deal coming to you, it's hitting your desk. And before you even see some of the back end products we just talked about, that the consumer's already bringing some negative equity to the trade, etcetera, etcetera, and the consumer's needing to get into a slightly longer term loan to manage the monthly payment. I I think some of the other things that we kinda highlighted in the study could be things that your underwriter could actually be taking into consideration. Right? Is the consumer making a prudent vehicle purchase decision? Right? Are they going from a luxury brand to a nonluxury brand? Are they going from an older... From a used... A a newer used car to an older used car? Right? I think some of those things from an underwriter perspective as you're talking to the dealer or talking to the member can be taken into consideration. Right? I think as the consumer wants to potentially be in that longer term loan, I think your head needs to go to, okay. I'm gonna do this, and they're gonna be underwater longer. Are we gonna be able to make sure that the member stays current and doesn't get in trouble with this loan? Right? I think those are the those are the conversations that you need to be having. Right? And and and it's a big question right now. Right? Because we are now... I was just having this conversation earlier this morning. If you remember the slide, 2021, 2022, used vehicle monthly payments shot vertically in, like, a six month period because of the shift in demand. Right? That also meant that if you were trading in a used car, you got a really nice offer from the dealership, but that then turned into somebody having to buy that more expensive used car. And now that we've kinda gotten out from underneath that, right, we don't have as much demand. So values have declined over that same time period to where we are today as the questioner has has correctly identified. So now we've got consumers that might typically have been in a forty eight month trade cycle coming in forty eight months into an eighty four month loan on a car that was potentially fifteen to twenty thousand dollars overpriced when they bought it, and they have no equity in the deal whatsoever, but they absolutely have to get into their next car. Right? So I think based on each of your individual program strategies and credit risk strategies, you're gonna have to make your own determination of how much of that negative equity are we willing to carry. What can we do to help the consumer? Can we hopefully maybe suggest a more prudent purchase decision as our data proved can affect the outcome of that? So I think there's a lot there that you could definitely be discussing with your dealerships and your underwriters, to make sure you protect the health of the portfolio. Thank you, TJ. Okay. We got four more here. Was there any data or insight regarding the migration from a loan to a lease as part of your analysis? Yeah. So great question. I think we we kind of just... It's inherently a part of the dataset because we included leases and loans from the 2024 population that got us started with this study. We didn't necessarily specifically isolate changes of performance from consumers that went from a loan to a lease. I think there's some very, very safe assumptions you can make about consumers that move from a loan to lease based on what we saw in the data. Right? PTI, we didn't just say, hey. PTI for loans versus PTI to leases. Right? It was PTI in general. Right? So consumers that are moving, you know, to a lower PTI are gonna have a better... Potentially a better outcome. Right? I would even say that even if that that that that loan to lease transition, was not necessarily a change in vehicle decision. So let's say, hypothetically, let's say they they went from a loan on a Toyota Camry to a lease on a Toyota Camry. I think we can all safely assume that lease payment was probably cheaper or at least on par with that loan payment from 2019 or 2020. Right? That's going to then, really be an indicator of a more positive payment outcome and performance outcome for that consumer that moved from loan to lease. So I I think at the end of the day, yes, there's probably some very, very sim... Very good similarities and better loan performance or better payment performance for consumers that went from loan to lease, really just because of the shift in PTI and monthly payments. And I'll be honest with you. I hear from a lot of customers and a lot of lenders outside of the credit union space that are sitting there contemplating, well, do I do eighty four month notes, or do I try to do a better job of pushing consumers into the leasing? Right? And you can imagine which customers are asking me that question. Right? So I think it's something that the broader market is talking about and thinking about, as consumers are coming back and and and obviously having to face this affordability crisis head on. Yeah. I like how you made that clear of, hey. The longer term for the right persona, it's a good move. Right? Yeah. So... Okay. Some more clarification for our statistical people out here. How did you calculate your loan to value ratio? Yeah. Great question. It's an all in LTV. So based on the amount finance reported to TransUnion, which as I mentioned on one of the previous questions, may include a variety of back end products or, obviously, negative equity from a prior transaction or trade in. So it is that full all in LTV amount financed. And then compared to vehicle values provided to us from our partners over at JD Power, if it's a new vehicle, we usually use MSRP as that base value for the vehicle. If it was a used vehicle, then we use a a fair trade in price for a fair condition car. Okay. What was the n or the sample size for each of your three segments? Yeah. Great question, Beth. I appreciate you putting your name in there on the chat, Beth. We did not do a sample size. So we we identified the 5,500,000 consumers that we saw that opened an auto loan or lease in 2024 that we were then able to link to a prior transaction within that six month or that six year window dating back to 2018. So it's possible that you opened an auto loan in 2024, but it was your first one on trade on the credit file, you got removed. If we weren't able to identify... If you had an older auto loan on your file, but we didn't see that you actually disposed of a vehicle to make that transaction in 2024, then you were also removed. So all of that said and done, let us down the 5,500,000 consumers that went into the study Based on the credit risk distribution that was on the prior... One of the slides in here, you can kinda see most of our consumers that that that in the population were in the prime and above segment, and I think 20% were in prime, and I think another 20 to 25% were in the nonprime space. Okay. This might be my favorite question because I remember us going from '60 to '72, '72 to '84. With more lenders moving to offer ninety six month and the cost of new cars increasing, do you foresee lenders extending terms to a 108 or even a 120? Great question. There are... I... There are already some lenders out there that have already pushed to a 108. Right? I think it's a very, very niche, very, very specific product for the right consumer in the right situation that needs the right thing. Ninety six month financing options are not pervasive. It's a thing that people like to talk about. There are some folks that do it, particularly in the credit union space. And I don't have the direct number off of my head, but I think a year ago when I looked at it, ninety six months were still less than, like, half a percent of the market. Right? So it's it's really not a meaningful thing that... That's moving a lot of needles. The other thing that we can't necessarily look at yet because, again, we just don't have enough volume. And for the ones that are out there, we don't have enough performance to be able to really measure and say what the impact is of these thing... Of these ninety six month notes and stuff like that. So I think it's still very, very early even on the ninety sixes to start talking about one o eights and one twenties. Right? With... You know, you know, I I think it's... Some folks are doing it because, yes, cars are really expensive. Some folks that do it are viewing it as a lease almost. Right? There's no expectation that the car is gonna... That the loan is gonna sit there for any meaningful amount of time. It's a product to serve the need of a particular member or consumer, and that's kinda where it is right now. But I think jury's still out. We still need to let some data kinda come through and see. But, yes, cars are expensive. I'm also really kind of... And Britt and I were talking about this before. What's the dealer component of these longer term loans? Right? Some dealer groups are not happy with eighty four month notes. Right? Why? Because that means the consumer's not gonna come and see me for, you know, maybe an extra twelve or twenty four months than I would have expected them to. Just wait until ninety six month notes start to potentially become pervasive. Dealers really, really aren't gonna like that. Right? So, you know, as I mentioned before, as lenders move into ninety sixes, does leasing then become a little bit more pervasive on the new car side? On the used car side, there's some pretty interesting startups out there that are talking about used vehicle leasing. Again, not very pervasive, but definitely, you know, I think very much a reaction to affordability, that we've been talking about. So, you know, we'll we'll we'll wait and see. We'll probably keep talking about it until, somebody decides, where we have enough data to kinda start to tell that story. Okay, Paul. We'll wrap with this. Or excuse me, TJ. A question from Paul. We'll wrap with this. Back to the payment to income that everyone's been excited about. It seemed to be generally predictive of performance regardless of the persona. Was there a level of that payment to income that you felt is most indicative? Yeah. I think if you go back through kinda the study and, like, the different segments that we do, and I'm I'm looking at it on my other screen so I have the I have the the luck or the ability to do that. You know, I would say that it it it depends on what your level of appetite is, right, from a risk perspective. You guys absolutely have to decide based on your risk profile what you're willing to do and where your members are and where your geography sits and all that stuff. You got to make that own determination. I would say that, like, when I look at the prudent purchaser segments across all three credit tiers that we showed, kinda, you know, in the nonprime, it was sub 6% was the prudent purchasers, which had great phenomenal performance. Right? In the prime space, it was kinda 4.5 to 9%, that segment. And then in the prudent purchasers for above prime, the prudent purchasers were kind of below 8.1%. Right? But, again, I think the key thing here, Paul, for that answer is that if... Yes. It is a very, very predictive attribute in our segmentation model was PTI across the board. No questions asked. Right? But I think the point of our study and what we were really interested to see was it's not the main determining factor. Right? Even with the higher PTI, if the consumer makes a more prudent purchase decision, the loans performed better. Right? Even if PTI was constant across that. Right? Even in the above prime space, as I highlighted, PTI above 8.1%, consumers that didn't switch to a lower cost vehicle actually performed, like, three times worse than consumers that did make a more prudent purchase decision. Right? So, yes, PTI is a determining factor. Is there a silver bullet or a line of demarcation? I... We can't tell you what that would be for your portfolio. The data doesn't even necessarily say yes. Like, stop here or don't go past this. Like, it's it's a data point to consider in combination with the holistic view of the deal. Excellent, TJ. Thanks for wrapping that back up. Everyone, thank you for your time today. On the screen is a coupon to join us for Lending Tech Live. Come see TJ. Come see the beard in person. Join us if you will. We'd love to have you. So thank you, TJ. Thank you, everyone. Until next time. Have a good one. Bye bye.
ON-DEMAND WEBINAR
Navigating the affordability squeeze
Auto loan stress doesn’t always start with a missed payment. For credit union lenders, the warning signs often show much earlier if you know what signals to look out for.
Discover a data-driven look at what 5.5 million financed vehicles reveals about today’s auto lending market. Together, we’ll unpack new TransUnion research to show what credit unions should be watching in their indirect portfolios, which borrower and financing decisions can indicate risk early, and why similar credit scores can still lead to very different outcomes.
Topics we’ll cover:
- Which LTV and delinquency trends matter most now?
- Why are auto payments and ownership costs still rising?
- What can lenders learn beyond the credit score?
- How can affordability profiles sharpen deal structure and risk decisions?
Share
Speaker
-
TJ Cox
Senior Director of Market Development - Auto | TransUnion -
Brit Barker (Moderator)
SVP of Sales | Origence
Trending content
-
Inside the economy with Steven Rick: Prepare your credit union for 2027Save your seatDecember 1011 a.m. P.T.
-
-